""" Variable Annuities Module Insurance products with variable returns based on mutual fund subaccounts CFA Standards: Insurance Products, Retirement Planning Key Concepts: - Deferred variable annuities (DVA) vs Variable immediate annuities (VIA) - Mortality and expense (M&E) fees (~1.25%) - Investment management fees (~0.75%) - Administrative fees (~0.15%) - Total costs: 2-3% annually - Tax deferral benefit overstated - Better alternatives: Low-cost index funds in taxable accounts Verdict: THE BAD - Expensive, tax-inefficient, illiquid Rating: 2/10 - High costs destroy value; rarely makes sense """ from decimal import Decimal, getcontext from typing import Dict, Any, List from datetime import datetime import logging from config import AssetParameters, AssetClass from base_analytics import AlternativeInvestmentBase logger = logging.getLogger(__name__) getcontext().prec = 28 class VariableAnnuityAnalyzer(AlternativeInvestmentBase): """ Variable Annuity Analyzer 1. HIGH COSTS: M&E (1.25%) + Fund fees (0.75%) + Admin (0.15%) = 2%+ 2. TAX TRAP: Converts LTCG to ordinary income 3. TAX DEFERRAL: Overstated benefit (index funds already tax-efficient) 4. ILLIQUIDITY: Surrender charges (typically 7 years) 5. COMPLEXITY: Riders, living benefits, death benefits add cost 6. BETTER ALTERNATIVE: Low-cost index fund in taxable account Verdict: THE BAD Rating: 2/10 - High costs fatal; rarely appropriate """ def __init__(self, parameters: AssetParameters): super().__init__(parameters) # Premium and account value self.premium = getattr(parameters, 'premium', Decimal('100000')) self.account_value = getattr(parameters, 'account_value', self.premium) # Fee structure (annual) self.mortality_expense_fee = getattr(parameters, 'mortality_expense_fee', Decimal('0.0125')) # 1.25% self.investment_mgmt_fee = getattr(parameters, 'investment_mgmt_fee', Decimal('0.0075')) # 0.75% self.admin_fee = getattr(parameters, 'admin_fee', Decimal('0.0015')) # 0.15% # Optional rider fees self.guaranteed_withdrawal_benefit = getattr(parameters, 'guaranteed_withdrawal_benefit', Decimal('0.0')) # 0-1% self.death_benefit_rider = getattr(parameters, 'death_benefit_rider', Decimal('0.0')) # 0-0.5% # Surrender charge schedule self.surrender_years = getattr(parameters, 'surrender_years', 7) self.initial_surrender_charge = getattr(parameters, 'initial_surrender_charge', Decimal('0.07')) # 7% # Tax rates self.ordinary_tax_rate = getattr(parameters, 'ordinary_tax_rate', Decimal('0.37')) self.ltcg_rate = getattr(parameters, 'ltcg_rate', Decimal('0.20')) # Age (for RMD and death benefit) self.age = getattr(parameters, 'age', 50) def total_annual_cost(self) -> Dict[str, Any]: """ Calculate total annual cost Key insight: Variable annuities typically cost 2-3% annually This is ENORMOUS drag on returns """ base_costs = self.mortality_expense_fee + self.investment_mgmt_fee + self.admin_fee rider_costs = self.guaranteed_withdrawal_benefit + self.death_benefit_rider total = base_costs + rider_costs # Cost in dollars annual_cost_dollars = total * self.account_value return { 'base_costs': { 'mortality_expense_fee': float(self.mortality_expense_fee), 'investment_mgmt_fee': float(self.investment_mgmt_fee), 'admin_fee': float(self.admin_fee), 'subtotal': float(base_costs) }, 'rider_costs': { 'guaranteed_withdrawal_benefit': float(self.guaranteed_withdrawal_benefit), 'death_benefit_rider': float(self.death_benefit_rider), 'subtotal': float(rider_costs) }, 'total_annual_cost_pct': float(total), 'total_annual_cost_dollars': float(annual_cost_dollars), 'analysis_note': 'Typical VA costs 2-3% annually - destroys returns over time' } def tax_deferral_myth(self, years: int = 20, gross_return: Decimal = Decimal('0.08')) -> Dict[str, Any]: """ Analyze tax deferral "benefit" Key insight: Tax deferral benefit is OVERSTATED - Index funds already tax-efficient (qualified div + LTCG) - VA converts gains to ORDINARY INCOME (higher rate) - High fees eat tax deferral benefit """ initial = Decimal('10000') # Variable Annuity path total_fees = self.mortality_expense_fee + self.investment_mgmt_fee + self.admin_fee va_net_return = gross_return - total_fees va_gross_value = initial * ((Decimal('1') + va_net_return) ** years) va_gain = va_gross_value - initial va_tax = va_gain * self.ordinary_tax_rate va_after_tax = va_gross_value - va_tax # Index fund path (taxable account) # Tax drag: ~0.3-0.5% annually for broad index fund tax_drag = Decimal('0.004') # 0.4% annual drag index_net_return = gross_return - tax_drag index_value_before_tax = initial * ((Decimal('1') + index_net_return) ** years) # Gains already taxed along the way, only final adjustment index_after_tax = index_value_before_tax # Comparison difference = index_after_tax - va_after_tax return { 'time_horizon_years': years, 'gross_annual_return': float(gross_return), 'variable_annuity': { 'annual_fees': float(total_fees), 'net_return': float(va_net_return), 'ending_value_before_tax': float(va_gross_value), 'tax_on_gains': float(va_tax), 'tax_rate': float(self.ordinary_tax_rate), 'final_value': float(va_after_tax) }, 'index_fund_taxable': { 'annual_tax_drag': float(tax_drag), 'net_return': float(index_net_return), 'final_value': float(index_after_tax) }, 'winner': 'Index Fund' if index_after_tax > va_after_tax else 'Variable Annuity', 'outperformance': float(difference), 'analysis_conclusion': 'Index fund beats VA despite "tax deferral" - fees and ordinary income tax kill VA' } def surrender_charge_schedule(self) -> Dict[str, Any]: """ Generate surrender charge schedule Key insight: Surrender charges trap your money Typically 7% declining to 0% over 7 years """ schedule = [] decline_per_year = self.initial_surrender_charge / Decimal(str(self.surrender_years)) for year in range(self.surrender_years + 1): charge_pct = max(Decimal('0'), self.initial_surrender_charge - (decline_per_year * Decimal(str(year)))) charge_dollars = charge_pct * self.account_value schedule.append({ 'year': year, 'surrender_charge_pct': float(charge_pct), 'surrender_charge_dollars': float(charge_dollars), 'net_value_if_surrendered': float(self.account_value - charge_dollars) }) return { 'surrender_period_years': self.surrender_years, 'initial_charge': float(self.initial_surrender_charge), 'schedule': schedule, 'analysis_warning': 'Surrender charges lock up money and create exit costs' } def death_benefit_analysis(self) -> Dict[str, Any]: """ Analyze death benefit Key insight: Death benefit is NOT insurance - Typically just return of premium (not a meaningful benefit) - Better to buy term life insurance separately """ # Typical death benefit = greater of account value or premium paid death_benefit = max(self.account_value, self.premium) # True insurance value insurance_value = death_benefit - self.account_value return { 'death_benefit': float(death_benefit), 'current_account_value': float(self.account_value), 'insurance_value': float(insurance_value), 'interpretation': 'No meaningful insurance value' if insurance_value <= 0 else 'Some downside protection', 'analysis_recommendation': 'Buy separate term life insurance instead - much cheaper' } def compare_to_alternatives(self) -> Dict[str, Any]: """ Compare VA to better alternatives Key insight: Multiple better alternatives exist """ return { 'variable_annuity': { 'annual_cost': float(self.mortality_expense_fee + self.investment_mgmt_fee + self.admin_fee), 'tax_treatment': 'Gains taxed as ordinary income (37% top bracket)', 'liquidity': f'Surrender charges for {self.surrender_years} years', 'complexity': 'High - riders, subaccounts, fees', 'transparency': 'Low - prospectus 100+ pages' }, 'alternative_1_index_fund_taxable': { 'annual_cost': '0.03-0.10% (index fund expense ratio)', 'tax_treatment': 'Qualified dividends (15%) + LTCG (20%)', 'liquidity': 'Full - sell anytime', 'complexity': 'Low - simple', 'transparency': 'High', 'analysis_preference': 'BEST for most investors' }, 'alternative_2_401k_or_ira': { 'annual_cost': '0.03-0.50% depending on plan', 'tax_treatment': 'Tax-deferred (traditional) or tax-free (Roth)', 'liquidity': 'Penalties before 59.5', 'complexity': 'Low', 'analysis_note': 'Max these out BEFORE considering VA' }, 'alternative_3_muni_bonds': { 'annual_cost': '0.05-0.20%', 'tax_treatment': 'Tax-free income', 'liquidity': 'Good', 'analysis_note': 'If in high tax bracket, consider for fixed income' } } def analysis_verdict(self) -> Dict[str, Any]: """verdict on Variable Annuities""" return { 'product': 'Variable Annuities', 'category': 'THE BAD', 'rating': '2/10', 'analysis_summary': 'Expensive, tax-inefficient, illiquid - rarely makes sense', 'key_problems': [ 'HIGH COSTS: 2-3% annual fees destroy returns', 'TAX TRAP: Converts LTCG (20%) to ordinary income (37%)', 'TAX DEFERRAL MYTH: Index funds already tax-efficient', 'ILLIQUIDITY: Surrender charges lock up money', 'COMPLEXITY: Difficult to understand and compare', 'COMMISSION DRIVEN: Salesperson makes 5-7% upfront' ], 'when_might_make_sense': [ 'Already maxed 401k, IRA, HSA, 529', 'Very long time horizon (20+ years)', 'High tax bracket + will be in lower bracket in retirement', 'Need guaranteed income rider (but annuitize regular annuity instead)' ], 'analysis_recommendation': 'AVOID for almost everyone', 'better_alternatives': [ '1st: Max 401k/IRA (tax-advantaged + lower costs)', '2nd: Taxable index funds (lower cost, better tax treatment)', '3rd: I Bonds, TIPS, Muni bonds (specific needs)', '4th: Fixed immediate annuity if need guaranteed income' ], 'analysis_quotes': [ '"Variable annuities are sold, not bought"', '"The only people making money on VAs are the insurance companies and salespeople"', '"Tax deferral is not worth 2% annual fees plus ordinary income tax"', '"Just buy low-cost index funds in a taxable account - you\'ll do better"' ], 'bottom_line': 'Costs and tax treatment make VAs poor choice; simple index funds superior' } def calculate_nav(self) -> Decimal: """Current account value""" return self.account_value def calculate_key_metrics(self) -> Dict[str, Any]: """Key VA metrics""" return { 'account_value': float(self.account_value), 'total_costs': self.total_annual_cost(), 'tax_deferral_analysis': self.tax_deferral_myth(), 'surrender_schedule': self.surrender_charge_schedule(), 'alternatives': self.compare_to_alternatives(), 'analysis_category': 'THE BAD' } def valuation_summary(self) -> Dict[str, Any]: """Valuation summary""" return { 'product_overview': { 'type': 'Variable Annuity', 'premium': float(self.premium), 'account_value': float(self.account_value), 'surrender_years': self.surrender_years, 'owner_age': self.age }, 'key_metrics': self.calculate_key_metrics(), 'analysis_category': 'THE BAD', 'recommendation': 'Avoid - use low-cost index funds instead' } def calculate_performance(self) -> Dict[str, Any]: """Performance metrics""" total_cost = self.mortality_expense_fee + self.investment_mgmt_fee + self.admin_fee return { 'total_annual_cost': float(total_cost), 'cost_drag_on_8pct_return': float(total_cost / Decimal('0.08')), 'note': 'High costs severely reduce returns over time' } # Export __all__ = ['VariableAnnuityAnalyzer']